Top 10 Historically Accurate Mystery Movies
#10: “Changeling” (2008)
Imagine your son goes missing and when he returns to you, safe and sound…it is not your son, but an impostor. And the authorities believe you’re mentally ill for not recognizing your son. This chilling award-winning drama about police corruption is actually based on real events, specifically the 1928 Wineville Chicken Coop murders. The real Walter had been killed by a child molestor. Although the film does have some composites, most characters are based on the actual people involved. The film’s faithfulness to its incredible premise even had critics believing the film was completely fictional. Would it were so.
#9: “Boston Strangler” (2023)
This film follows the true story of journalist Loretta McLaughlin, who broke the story of serial killer the Boston Strangler in the ‘60s. Loretta and her fellow reporter are faced with resistance and period-typical sexism in pursuing the investigation. The film uses composites and is inaccurate in minor respects. Authors also debate whether DeSalvo was the only serial killer or whether there were multiple ones. However, the film is overall faithful to the real case and events. Some of Loretta’s actual writings even make it into the film as voice-over. Now that’s attention to detail.
#8: “Mississippi Burning” (1988)
This grim tale of the struggle for civil rights is based on an all-too real story. In the film, as in real life, FBI agents investigate the mysterious disappearance of three civil rights activists after they are arrested by the local police force. While the film was praised by critics, backlash over the film’s focus on the white characters followed its release. Though the film took liberties in depicting the actual crime and investigation, the film’s depiction of Southern hostility and racism was right on the money. The county jail’s ties to the Ku Klux Klan is also very much true.
#7: “Memories of Murder” (2003)
This South Korean film by Bong Joon-ho, the director of “Parasite” is predictably hard-hitting. Based on the first real-life serial murders in Korea, the film follows local detective Park Doo-man in attempting to solve the mystery. Park struggles with police incompetence, lack of forensic technology, and clashes with his partners. Unfortunately, the crime was unsolved at the time of the film, but Bong Joon-ho uses that fact to create an unsettling ending. Although the film compressed the timeline, it also included details directly from the murder case and included the actual case’s non-resolution. The film’s focus on procedural inefficiency and incompetence is also true to real life.
#6: “Fire in the Sky” (1993)
Top 10 Kids' Movies with the Most Fire Soundtracks
Aliens aren’t real…or are they? Whichever side of the fence you land on, this film’s depiction of Travis Walton’s real-life account of extraterrestrial abduction is faithful to events—give or take the alien abduction. For one thing, there was an actual media circus around his disappearance, as well as Walton’s family’s reactions. While the film does depict the aliens as real through flashback, the actual abduction scenes are not true to Walton’s account, with the director deciding they were too far-fetched. Though the film ultimately does land on the side of aliens, the terrestrial details—as far as anyone can tell—are true to life.
#5: “Chinatown” (1974)
This award-winning classic film has this sterling accolade: Fidelity to its real-life inspiration. Sure, it takes some liberties along the way. But this taut thriller about false identities, infidelity, and water rights and wars is firmly rooted in actual events. In real life a businessman did steal water from a small town to the benefit of the city of L.A. The conspiracy was vast, including famous and influential figures like William Mulholland, and even more corrupt than even the film’s depiction. This is definitely a case of real life being far stranger than fiction.
#4: “The Good Nurse” (2022)
Top 10 Historically Accurate Details in Disney Movies
A heroic nurse learns that her co-worker is a serial killer. Sounds crazy, right? Actually, the film is based on real-life events, and faithful except for minor details. Amy Loughren befriends fellow nurse Charles Cullen, who helps hide her heart condition from the rest of the hospital. However, her feelings about him change as she starts to suspect Cullen’s involvement in a series of mysterious hospital deaths. The film focuses only on Cullens’ final murders and arrest due to Loughren’s investigation. Even better, the real Loughren herself was a consultant on the film. Even the film’s inaccuracies were for a good reason: The victims’ names were indeed changed in the movies to prevent re-traumatizing their families. All in all, a truthful recounting.
#3: “All Good Things” (2010)
Top 10 Most Historically Accurate Costumes in Movies
The mysterious disappearance of the wife of a real estate heir—and suspected murderer—forms the premise of this 2020 film. Though based on the real-life Robert Durst, the film changed all the names and is all in all loosely based on the true crime. Or is it? Five years after the movie’s release, Durst himself came out in support of the movie, saying how much he enjoyed it, and admitted the film was spot-on about how he did the murders. Talk about an endorsement! To this day, Durst’s wife’s whereabouts are unknown. Hopefully it’s somewhere far away from her husband.
#2: “In Cold Blood” (1967)
Top 10 Historically Accurate Movies
Truman Capote’s true crime classic received a famously true crime film adaptation. “In Cold Blood” portrays the murders of the Clutter family by two men in Kansas. The film is largely faithful to the book. Capote even chose the director, Richard Brooks, for the adaptation and was struck by the resemblance the two actors had to the murderers. Brooks was indeed committed to realism, shooting it in almost documentary-style black and white. He even filmed many scenes in the same locations in Kansas, including the real-life Clutter house. Though Capote’s research was not perfect, the film’s dedication to realism makes this seminal film really true to life.
#1: “Zodiac” (2007)
Top 10 Things Zodiac Got Factually Right and Wrong
The notorious Zodiac killings remain one of the United States’ most infamous cases to this day. Though the crime may never be solved, David Fincher’s film is meticulous in its fidelity to the real-life case. The movie includes many true details, such as the police almost catching the Zodiac Killer but mistaking him for a civilian, and the Zodiac Killer threatening to blow up school children. Several of these incidents are based on cartoonist Robert Graysmith’s own investigation of the case, which the film also portrays accurately. The film does fictionalize some elements, but with commitment to historical accuracy this faithful, it only serves to make the film all the more uncannily true.
