Top 10 Shocking Confessions on Watch What Happens Live

When Jennifer Lawrence appeared to play Plead the Fifth, we knew it would be entertaining. Andy asked her if she had ever shared an off-screen kiss with her on-screen costar Liam Hemsworth. Lawrence and Hemsworth worked on the “Hunger Games” franchise together, where they played old friends with some romantic tension. She was unapologetic about the fact that she had gotten cozy with Liam even when the cameras weren’t rolling, asking Andy if he wouldn’t have done the same thing. We honestly can’t say we’re that surprised!

When Andy played Plead the Fifth with “Friends” star Matthew Perry, he was clearly trying to get some dirt on what went on behind the scenes. Perry denied that there was any hanky panky going on between the co-stars, and refused to play “Shag, Marry, or Kill” about the actresses on the show. What he DID reveal however was that there was once a storyline pitched that he quickly nixed that involved Chandler going to a male strip club because they offered such delicious sandwiches. Doesn’t that sound like something Joey would have done?

When Gerard Butler played Plead the Fifth, he was first asked about which movie he did just for the paycheque...which he refused to respond to. The next question was a doozy too, though. Andy stated that Butler had kissed two co-stars on screen, Angelina Jolie and Jennifer Aniston, and asked who was a better kisser. (Butler worked with Jolie on “Lara Croft: Tomb Raider – The Cradle of Life” and with Aniston in “The Bounty Hunter”.) He may have surprised some viewers when he confidently went with . . . Jen!

When Anne Hathaway appeared on “Watch What Happens Live”, Andy addressed some rumors that she had been spotted holding a large joint. He used his first question to ask her to rate herself on a scale of one to ten as to how big of a stoner she was. She responded coyly, saying that she “wasn’t a little one” but expressed concern about being totally honest considering her status as a parent and the fact that she didn’t want to get in trouble with the law. It’s okay Anne, your silence says it all!

Andy Cohen always seems to know just the right questions to ask. For Kevin Hart’s turn playing Plead the Fifth, Andy asked him what the most money was that he had spent at a strip club in one night. Andy speculated that it was around seven thousand. He was shocked when Hart actually admitted that the number was more than twice that, estimating it at 15 thousand bucks! Kevin tried to justify the massive expense by saying that he was treating the people he was with, but that’s still a whopping bill for a single night.

Andy Cohen used one of Cameron Diaz’s own quotes to corner her when it was her time to play Plead the Fifth. He referenced her saying that all women had been attracted to another woman at some point, and asked whether she had ever acted on that attraction. While she at first seemed bashful, she ended up handling the very personal question with grace and admitted that yes, she had in fact been with a woman. She didn’t specify in exactly what capacity, and left that up to the viewer’s imagination.

Kim Kardashian was famously married to her ex, Kris Humphries, for a mere 72 days before filing for divorce. But many have wondered whether her heart was really in it. When Kim took the stage with Andy and fielded questions from the audience, she was asked what her least favorite “Keeping Up With the Kardashians” spin off was. She responded that it was the one that took place with her and Kourtney in New York because she was going through a rough time in life. Andy followed up and asked her whether she went into her marriage knowing it was going to fail, and she responded that she knew by the time they were on their honeymoon.

Anne Hathaway may have been reluctant to be totally honest about her marijuana use, but Susan Sarandon sure wasn’t! When Andy asked her to name a major Hollywood event that she had attended while under the influence, she scoffed and replied, “ . . . only one?” Then she gave a serious answer, saying she had gone to basically every major Hollywood event stoned save one exception: the Oscars. While she was willing to be honest about her weed use, she plead the fifth when it came to her sex life and who she had hooked up with in Hollywood.

Shania Twain appeared alongside Patricia Arquette in one episode of Watch What Happens Live and the trio played a game where Andy had to guess which of these entertainers a surprising fact pertained to. He was quick to point a finger at Shania when he was forced to guess which of the two women had peed herself in front of an audience… several times. And he was right: Shania owned the story, explaining how she’d cleverly knocked over a glass of water to conceal the mess. Let’s just say thank goodness she was wearing a skirt!

Before we unveil our top pick, here are a few honorable mentions:

Patti LuPone Doesn’t Respect Madonna’s Acting

Drew Barrymore Ghosted Christian Bale

Joe Playing “Shag, Marry, or Kill” About His Exes

Gwyneth Paltrow Has Done Ecstasy

We all know that there has been beef between two pop divas, Pink and Christina Aguilera. But when Pink had to play Plead the Fifth she said that the two performers had made amends. She did however call back to an earlier time where she alleges she and Xtina were in a club together and Aguilera swung at her. Interestingly, Christina refuted these claims when she appeared on the show a couple of years later, saying that she remembered the night totally differently, claiming it involved a game of spin the bottle where Pink got shy when it came time for the two to kiss.