Top 20 Most Underrated Movies of the 2000s

Two years after the Johnny Cash biopic "Walk the Line" won an Oscar, producer-co-writer Judd Apatow came out with an incredible spoof of it. “Walk Hard: The Dewey Cox Story” is a sharp and absurd parody that aims at every music biopic trope imaginable. Following the life of fictional rock legend Dewey Cox, the film skewers everything from "Walk the Line" to "Ray." With its outrageous humor, surprisingly catchy songs, and an all-star cast of comedic heavyweights, it should have been a runaway hit. Yet, despite rave reviews, it bombed at the box office. Maybe it was ahead of its time, or maybe audiences weren’t ready for its level of meta-humor. Either way, "Walk Hard" has become a cult classic.

“Lars and the Real Girl” is the kind of heartfelt oddball story that, on its face, shouldn’t work. Ryan Gosling delivers a career-defining performance as Lars, a socially isolated man who finds companionship in Bianca, a life-sized doll he orders online. What could have been a crass or ridiculous premise is instead handled with warmth and compassion. Long before our current 'loneliness epidemic,' the film explored loneliness and the human need for connection. Despite critical acclaim, this quirky gem flew under the radar for many audiences. It’s a quiet masterpiece that reminds us that even the strangest stories can hold a mirror to the deepest parts of ourselves.

“Synecdoche, New York” is the kind of arthouse film that gets under your skin and refuses to leave. Written and directed by Charlie Kaufman, it follows theater director Caden Cotard[b], played by Philip Seymour Hoffman. When Cotard's life falls apart, he finds solace in the theater. He attempts to recreate his entire life inside a massive warehouse for a never-ending play. It’s an intricate, surreal exploration of mortality, identity, and the futility of artistic ambition. While critics praised its ambition, the film’s layered narrative and bleak tone left mainstream audiences puzzled. But for those who connect with its themes, "Synecdoche, New York" is a profound, almost overwhelming experience.

Spike Lee’s “25th Hour” is a raw, deeply reflective drama that stands as a time capsule of post-9/11 New York City. The film follows Edward Norton's Monty in the final hours before he begins a seven-year prison sentence. As we go along with Monty's journey, we explore his regret and the fragile connections to his friends. As the first major movie filmed in NYC after 9/11, it captures the city’s somber, shell-shocked atmosphere with unflinching honesty. The haunting visuals, poignant performances, and a blistering monologue from Norton elevate it to masterpiece status. Despite its critical acclaim, “25th Hour” remains overshadowed by flashier films of the era.

Directed by Rian Johnson and starring a younger, subtler Joseph Gordon-Levitt, “Brick” is one of the best thrillers of the decade – that no one saw. Playing out like a hardboiled detective story set in high school, “Brick” borrows heavily from classic noir stories in the vein of Dashiell Hammett, and is every bit as entertaining and complex. It has a well-developed story with rich characters, and the high school setting provides a great modern twist on the old-school detective story. Today, it’s a cult classic.

“Primer” is a low-budget marvel that redefined sci-fi storytelling with its mind-bending take on time travel. Written, directed, and starring Shane Carruth[c], the film follows two engineers who accidentally invent a time machine. Their journeys through time quickly spiral into paranoia and existential dread. With its dense dialogue and intricate plotting, “Primer” expects audiences to keep up, offering no easy explanations or hand-holding. While this complexity turned off casual viewers, it earned the film a cult following among those who relish its intellectual challenge. Made for just $7,000, “Primer” proves that you don’t need a blockbuster budget to create a timeless or mind-bending classic.

Robin Williams trades in his trademark off-beat warmth for a new brand of silent intensity in “One Hour Photo.” It is easily one of the creepiest performances of his career. Williams plays Sy Parrish[d], a lonely photo technician who becomes dangerously obsessed with a family whose pictures he develops. The film unfolds as a slow-burn psychological thriller, exploring themes of isolation, voyeurism, and the dark underbelly of everyday life. Williams’ portrayal of Sy is both unsettling and tragically human, showing a side of the beloved actor that few had seen before. Despite critical praise, “One Hour Photo” never quite reached the heights of Williams’ more mainstream hits.

Danny Boyle’s “Sunshine” is a gripping sci-fi thriller that’s equal parts awe-inspiring and nerve-wracking. Set in the not-too-distant future, it follows a crew of astronauts tasked with reigniting our solar system's dying sun. The film is a stunning visual spectacle, oscillating between almost poetic beauty and white-knuckled terror. Alex Garland’s screenplay balances high-concept science with human struggle. The stellar ensemble cast - pun intended - delivers intense and shockingly grounded performances. The third act’s shift into psychological horror isn't for everyone, and to some, it feels off-putting. Still, “Sunshine” remains a visually and emotionally powerful film that deserves more love.

Directed by George Clooney and with an all-star cast that includes Drew Barrymore, Julia Roberts, and Clooney himself, it really is a wonder why this movie never caught on. The film follows the biographical story of Chuck Barris, a game show host who claimed to be an assassin working for the CIA. The actors are all fantastic, most notably the perpetually underrated Sam Rockwell as Barris, and the sets and cinematography capture the era perfectly. Mixing dark humor with intense drama, the movie finds a perfect balance and creates a unique, sadly overlooked experience.

Inspired by the life of timeless performer Bob Dylan, this movie uses non-traditional techniques to achieve its distinctive feel. Many famous actors portray the different facets of Dylan, including Heath Ledger and Christian Bale, but it’s Cate Blanchett who steals the show, receiving an Academy Award nomination for her stellar performance. It’s a weird and intimidating film, but it’s all for the sake of artistic merit, and in that sense, the film is flawless. Dylan even praised the movie and its actors in a Rolling Stone article, calling them “incredible,” so at least it wasn’t overlooked by its subject.

Another movie with another amazing performance by Sam Rockwell, “Moon” is a grossly underrated science fiction film that attempts to tackle heavy themes and questions while looking great in the process. The movie follows an astronaut as he faces a crisis after being alone for three years on the moon. It’s a dark and lonely picture filled with elegant, spacious cinematography, but it’s Rockwell’s Oscar-snubbed performance that pulls at our heartstrings. It could be considered the next great sci-fi experience, if people would actually watch it.

It took the comedic brilliance of Christopher Guest to figure out how to make a dog show the setting of one of America's greatest comedy films. Shot in a mockumentary style, "Best in Show" follows a quirky and absurd ensemble of dog enthusiasts as they prepare for the prestigious Mayflower Kennel Club Dog Show. From neurotic yuppies to eccentric trainers, the characters are as lovable as they are ridiculous. The huge ensemble is led by future "Schitt's Creek" stars Eugene Levy and Catherine O’Hara. While comedy fans adore it, “Best in Show” was a quiet, intellectual quirk-fest lost in an era of in-your-face humor.

Some of the best films of the 2000s are small movies with big stars that defy genre conventions. Enter “Stranger than Fiction,” a rare Will Ferrell dramedy. While caught in absurd situations, Ferrell plays Harold Crick (relatively) straight. Crick is an IRS auditor whose meticulously mundane life is upended when he begins hearing a narrator describe both his every move and his impending death. The film is an oh-so-delicate balance between humor, existential musings, and heartfelt emotion. Emma Thompson, Maggie Gyllenhaal, and Dustin Hoffman deliver standout performances. Its clever premise and touching exploration of free will and destiny make it a truly unique experience.

To put it bluntly, “In Bruges” is hands down one of the smartest, deftest comedies ever made. Written and directed by Martin McDonagh, the film follows hitmen Ray and Ken played by Colin Farrell and Brendan Gleeson. Ray botched a job, so they're hiding out in the picturesque Belgian town of Bruges. The duo’s chemistry is electric, with Farrell’s guilt-ridden rookie clashing perfectly against Gleeson’s weary veteran. The gorgeous medieval backdrop contrasts sharply with the film’s bloody, morally complex narrative. With witty dialogue, poignant themes of redemption, and a career-defining turn from Farrell, “In Bruges” was a critical powerhouse. It received only a limited release in the U.S., but its audience mainly grew thanks to DVD sales and, eventually, streaming.

Tom Hanks has made an entire career out of being a relatable everyman. You can literally count the movies where he plays a bad guy on one hand. One of those films was 2002's "Road to Perdition." It's a haunting crime drama about a murderous father seeking vengeance while accompanied by his young son. Paul Newman shines as Hanks' conflicted boss and father figure, in one of his final roles. Jude Law's sadistic assassin chills the bone every time he appears on screen. The film's cinematography paints every frame like a somber masterpiece, from rain-soaked streets to the iconic final showdown on a misty beach. It’s a gripping tale of loyalty, legacy, and the cost of redemption.

Fresh off his turn as Maximus in "Gladiator," Russell Crowe donned a blonde wig for his next period film. "Master and Commander" is a nautical epic, based on the award-winning book series about Napoleonic war hero Jack Aubrey. Crowe's Aubrey is a brilliant yet headstrong leader supported by his best friend, doctor, and naturalist Dr. Stephen Maturin[e]. The film’s attention to historical detail is unparalleled. From the creak of wooden decks to the thundering cannons, viewers are immersed in the Napoleonic Wars. The film won widespread critical acclaim, netting numerous Oscar nominations. The audience wasn't huge as the film was overshadowed by 2003's "Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl."

An overlooked classic in the crime comedy genre, this movie centers on a thief who is posing as an actor in Hollywood that gets caught in the middle of a murder investigation. Co-stars Robert Downey, Jr. and Val Kilmer share terrific chemistry, and the movie features one of Downey Jr.’s most overlooked roles, as he is truly hilarious. The comedy is sharp and the action is gritty, with the movie blending so many genres together it becomes a biting satire on classic hard-edged stories.

This movie was written and directed by Wes Anderson, and features all of his trademark quirkiness, eccentricity, and originality, which make for a fun, if awkward, time. It’s filled with terrific performances by an all-star cast, most notably Bill Murray as Steve, a man who sets out to find the shark that killed his friend. While Wes is becoming more popular today, this movie proved too strange for audiences, receiving mixed reviews and bombing with a box-office performance of only $35 million.

A unique title for a unique movie, it lets the audience know right away what they’re getting into, which is a terrific story leading up to the titular historic killing of Jesse James by Robert Ford. Starring Brad Pitt and Casey Affleck, respectively, they become their characters through hypnotic performances, and the movie is completed by memorably beautiful and desolate cinematography. It deserves a spot in the pantheon of great Westerns, but sadly, it bombed at the box office and has failed to make an impression.

Hollywood is rife with films 'based on a true story,' but few filmmakers were as brave or speculative as David Fincher in his film “Zodiac.” The film is a deep dive into the real-life Zodiac Killer case, following a pair of journalists and a detective as they try to uncover the identity of the infamous murderer. Fincher’s trademark precision brings the 1970s to life, immersing viewers in the paranoia and unease that gripped California during the killer’s spree. Its deliberate pacing and chilling atmosphere elevate it above standard crime dramas. At the time, though, it struggled to find an audience before becoming a cult classic.


Think we missed the mark? Drop your favorite hidden gem in the comments.

[b](KAY-den KOH-tard)
[c](SHAYN kuh-RUTH)
[d]SYE PAIR-ish)
[e](STEE-vun MA-chuh-rin)
[f]The LIFE uh-KWA-tik with STEEV ZEE-soo