Frozen VS Frozen 2
advertisement
VOICE OVER: Emily - WatchMojo
WRITTEN BY: Nick Spake
If you're still debating which film is better, you can let it go because we have the answer. Welcome to MsMojo and for this installment of versus, we're pitting “Frozen” against “Frozen II.”
“Frozen” took the world by storm when it hit theaters in 2013, setting a new gold standard for Disney's animated musical fairytales. “Frozen II” stands out as one of the best Disney sequels, expanding upon its predecessor's lore in exciting new ways. Like snowflakes, both films have their own distinctive features, but which one takes the crown? Venture with us into the unknown to find out…
“Frozen” took the world by storm when it hit theaters in 2013, setting a new gold standard for Disney's animated musical fairytales. “Frozen II” stands out as one of the best Disney sequels, expanding upon its predecessor's lore in exciting new ways. Like snowflakes, both films have their own distinctive features, but which one takes the crown? Venture with us into the unknown to find out…
If you’re still debating which film is better, you can let it go because we have the answer. Welcome to MsMojo and for this installment of versus, we’re pitting “Frozen” against “Frozen II.”
“Frozen” took the world by storm when it hit theaters in 2013, setting a new gold standard for Disney’s animated musical fairytales. “Frozen II” stands out as one of the best Disney sequels, expanding upon its predecessor’s lore in exciting new ways. Like snowflakes, both films have their own distinctive features, but which one takes the crown? Venture with us into the unknown to find out…
Round 1: Story
Loosely based on Hans Christian Andersen’s “The Snow Queen,” “Frozen” is a classic fairytale in all the right ways and a modern fairytale in all the right ways. The story encompasses all the Disney tropes we love: romance, magic, princesses, etc. Yet, it evolves these tropes for 21st century audiences, acknowledging that you can’t marry someone you just met, using magic as an allegory for overcoming adversity, and having one of our two princesses become a queen. The film is self-aware about these updates without feeling forced. It’s a timeless tale that speaks to adults and children alike, overflowing with charm, humor, and emotion.
In many respects, “Frozen II” is a more mature movie, taking our heroes into an eerie wilderness crawling with new challenges and new mysteries. With a darker tone, however, comes a more complex story. Just as the characters get lost in the woods, there are instances where the plot can become a tad convoluted. While the story does delve deeper into this world’s mythology and gives us several satisfying answers, it also leaves us with quite a few lingering questions. Maybe these questions will be answered in another sequel, but this does make “Frozen II” feel like a bridge to the next chapter.
“Frozen” works as a standalone story that audiences of all ages can gravitate towards. We appreciate the more adult narrative of “Frozen 2,” especially since the characters and the viewers are older. The plot juggles so many different ideas, though, that summarizing it is easier said than done. Even Olaf can explain the first movie’s story, which is ultimately more memorable. Point goes to “Frozen.”
WINNER: Frozen 1 / Frozen II 0
Round 2: Characters
The first film gives us two empowering heroines in sisters Anna and Elsa. Where Anna is outgoing and eager to find love, Elsa closes herself off from the world due her ice powers. Despite having contrasting personalities, the powerful bond between these sisters drives the film forward. Along the way, we encounter solid comedic relief in the talkative snowman Olaf, the silent reindeer Sven, and iceman Kristoff, whose cynical heart is melted by Anna’s warmth. While the film’s surprise villain could’ve backfired, this revelation does come as a genuine shock and effectively ties into Anna’s character arc as she learns what true love is.
The sisters continue to grow as people in “Frozen 2.” Elsa has an almost Jedi-like storyline as she explores the origins of her powers. Anna, meanwhile, takes on more responsibility and emerges as a true leader. As strong as our leads are, the filmmakers don’t always know what to do with the supporting cast. Although Olaf and Kristoff serve purposes in the grand scheme, there are times when it feels like they’re just going along for the ride. We’re also introduced to new characters like the Northuldra tribe, a group of Arendellian soldiers, and elemental spirits. Yet, they’re all somewhat underdeveloped, leaving us wanting more.
“Frozen” knew exactly how much screen time to give each member of the cast. “Frozen II” has some great character development for Elsa and Anna, but everyone else feels sidelined or underutilized. Plus, as much as the sisters evolve, there are instances when they take a step backwards, especially whenever Elsa tries pushing Anna away. Winner: “Frozen.”
WINNER: Frozen 2 / Frozen II 0
Round 3: Animation
It may not technically be a Christmas movie, but we’ll always associate “Frozen” with the holidays thanks to its vibrant frosty backdrops and cool color scheme. The elegant environments that the animators create define the term, “winter wonderland.” Although it’s CG animated, many of the designs and layouts are reminiscent of Disney’s hand-drawn features, striking the perfect balance between traditional artistry and new animation techniques. The filmmakers were heavily influenced by Scandinavian culture, which definitely shines through in the production design. The enchanting look of the film makes us want to visit Norway, especially during the snowier seasons.
There was a six-year gap between the releases of these films and the evolution of animation during that timeframe is evident in “Frozen II.” Some of the advances are subtle, such as the little details in clothing and hair. Others pop out at the audience, like the effects used to create the Dark Sea where Elsa tames the Nøkk, a water horse. As realistic as the water looks, it never enters that uncomfortable uncanny valley territory. Where the first film was all about winter, the autumn season provides a mysterious, yet enticing, backdrop here. Brimming with atmosphere, every location is a breath of fresh air.
It only makes sense that the newer film would be more technologically impressive. While “Frozen” has a brighter, more cheerful ambiance, the animators really upped their game and invented new software to make the sequel as dazzling as possible, securing its victory for this round.
WINNER: Frozen 2 / Frozen II 1
Round 4: Music
We can’t talk about the music in “Frozen” without bringing up the Oscar-winning “Let It Go.” As phenomenal as Elsa’s power ballad is, it often overshadows the film’s other songs, which are also generally amazing. You’re guaranteed to cry a frozen tear by the end of “Do You Want to Build a Snowman?” “For the First Time in Forever” wonderfully establishes Anna and Elsa’s contrasting personalities. “Love Is an Open Door” works as both a love song and a cautionary tale about rushing into a relationship. “In Summer” is surreally hilarious and even “Fixer Upper,” while not 100% necessary, possesses an infectiously catchy beat nonetheless.
“Frozen II” sees the return of song-writing team Robert Lopez and Kristen Anderson-Lopez and the score’s composer, Christophe Beck. Just as the story is more grown-up, their music sounds more sophisticated too. We still get a couple upbeat songs like “Some Things Never Change” and “When I Am Older,” as well as a retro 80s tune from Kristoff entitled “Lost in the Woods.” The best songs are the ones that bring out the inner demons and desires of our characters, such as “Into the Unknown,” “The Next Right Thing,” and “Show Yourself.” These songs take Elsa and Anna to bold new places, signifying their growth.
While we’ll be listening to both of these soundtracks until the end of time, let’s be honest. “Into the Unknown” is “Let It Go 2.0” and “Show Yourself” is “Let It Go 3.0.” “Frozen II” even begrudgingly acknowledges that the first film has a legacy in its music that’s hard to run from, making “Frozen” this round’s victory.
WINNER: Frozen 3 / Frozen II 1
Round 5: Messages & Themes
True love has always been a staple of Disney, but “Frozen” demonstrates how this doesn’t only apply to romance. Familial love can be just as meaningful, if not more so. Granted, “Frozen” wasn’t the first Disney movie to explore the bond of sisterhood, as “Lilo & Stitch” also had a touching relationship between Lilo and Nani. Where that was a subplot, though, Anna and Elsa’s connection is the focal point of “Frozen.” Learning that true love comes in many different forms, Anna becomes more careful with who she gives her heart to while Elsa finally starts opening up her heart to others.
Given its more adult tone, it makes sense that “Frozen II” would tackle themes of maturity and accepting change. At its core, however, this sequel is about learning to love oneself. As far as they’ve come from the first film, Anna remains codependent on others while Elsa is still coming to terms with the mysterious magic within herself. By the conclusion, Anna not only grows more independent, but also finds the strength and confidence to make difficult decisions on her own. Elsa walks away with a better understanding of who she is and where she belongs. Yet, neither loses sight of their loved ones.
These two films - just like the sisters - form a complete whole. Ideas that were introduced in the first film, like figuring out who you are and the different kinds of love, get elaborated upon with the importance of self-love in the sequel. “Frozen II” elevates “Frozen” in key ways, but you can't have one without the other. So, we’re calling this round a tie.
WINNER: Frozen 3 / Frozen II 2
They may finish each other’s sandwiches, but “Frozen” is ultimately the more well-thought out and rewatchable film, winning this versus with a final score of 3 to 2.
“Frozen” took the world by storm when it hit theaters in 2013, setting a new gold standard for Disney’s animated musical fairytales. “Frozen II” stands out as one of the best Disney sequels, expanding upon its predecessor’s lore in exciting new ways. Like snowflakes, both films have their own distinctive features, but which one takes the crown? Venture with us into the unknown to find out…
Round 1: Story
Loosely based on Hans Christian Andersen’s “The Snow Queen,” “Frozen” is a classic fairytale in all the right ways and a modern fairytale in all the right ways. The story encompasses all the Disney tropes we love: romance, magic, princesses, etc. Yet, it evolves these tropes for 21st century audiences, acknowledging that you can’t marry someone you just met, using magic as an allegory for overcoming adversity, and having one of our two princesses become a queen. The film is self-aware about these updates without feeling forced. It’s a timeless tale that speaks to adults and children alike, overflowing with charm, humor, and emotion.
In many respects, “Frozen II” is a more mature movie, taking our heroes into an eerie wilderness crawling with new challenges and new mysteries. With a darker tone, however, comes a more complex story. Just as the characters get lost in the woods, there are instances where the plot can become a tad convoluted. While the story does delve deeper into this world’s mythology and gives us several satisfying answers, it also leaves us with quite a few lingering questions. Maybe these questions will be answered in another sequel, but this does make “Frozen II” feel like a bridge to the next chapter.
“Frozen” works as a standalone story that audiences of all ages can gravitate towards. We appreciate the more adult narrative of “Frozen 2,” especially since the characters and the viewers are older. The plot juggles so many different ideas, though, that summarizing it is easier said than done. Even Olaf can explain the first movie’s story, which is ultimately more memorable. Point goes to “Frozen.”
WINNER: Frozen 1 / Frozen II 0
Round 2: Characters
The first film gives us two empowering heroines in sisters Anna and Elsa. Where Anna is outgoing and eager to find love, Elsa closes herself off from the world due her ice powers. Despite having contrasting personalities, the powerful bond between these sisters drives the film forward. Along the way, we encounter solid comedic relief in the talkative snowman Olaf, the silent reindeer Sven, and iceman Kristoff, whose cynical heart is melted by Anna’s warmth. While the film’s surprise villain could’ve backfired, this revelation does come as a genuine shock and effectively ties into Anna’s character arc as she learns what true love is.
The sisters continue to grow as people in “Frozen 2.” Elsa has an almost Jedi-like storyline as she explores the origins of her powers. Anna, meanwhile, takes on more responsibility and emerges as a true leader. As strong as our leads are, the filmmakers don’t always know what to do with the supporting cast. Although Olaf and Kristoff serve purposes in the grand scheme, there are times when it feels like they’re just going along for the ride. We’re also introduced to new characters like the Northuldra tribe, a group of Arendellian soldiers, and elemental spirits. Yet, they’re all somewhat underdeveloped, leaving us wanting more.
“Frozen” knew exactly how much screen time to give each member of the cast. “Frozen II” has some great character development for Elsa and Anna, but everyone else feels sidelined or underutilized. Plus, as much as the sisters evolve, there are instances when they take a step backwards, especially whenever Elsa tries pushing Anna away. Winner: “Frozen.”
WINNER: Frozen 2 / Frozen II 0
Round 3: Animation
It may not technically be a Christmas movie, but we’ll always associate “Frozen” with the holidays thanks to its vibrant frosty backdrops and cool color scheme. The elegant environments that the animators create define the term, “winter wonderland.” Although it’s CG animated, many of the designs and layouts are reminiscent of Disney’s hand-drawn features, striking the perfect balance between traditional artistry and new animation techniques. The filmmakers were heavily influenced by Scandinavian culture, which definitely shines through in the production design. The enchanting look of the film makes us want to visit Norway, especially during the snowier seasons.
There was a six-year gap between the releases of these films and the evolution of animation during that timeframe is evident in “Frozen II.” Some of the advances are subtle, such as the little details in clothing and hair. Others pop out at the audience, like the effects used to create the Dark Sea where Elsa tames the Nøkk, a water horse. As realistic as the water looks, it never enters that uncomfortable uncanny valley territory. Where the first film was all about winter, the autumn season provides a mysterious, yet enticing, backdrop here. Brimming with atmosphere, every location is a breath of fresh air.
It only makes sense that the newer film would be more technologically impressive. While “Frozen” has a brighter, more cheerful ambiance, the animators really upped their game and invented new software to make the sequel as dazzling as possible, securing its victory for this round.
WINNER: Frozen 2 / Frozen II 1
Round 4: Music
We can’t talk about the music in “Frozen” without bringing up the Oscar-winning “Let It Go.” As phenomenal as Elsa’s power ballad is, it often overshadows the film’s other songs, which are also generally amazing. You’re guaranteed to cry a frozen tear by the end of “Do You Want to Build a Snowman?” “For the First Time in Forever” wonderfully establishes Anna and Elsa’s contrasting personalities. “Love Is an Open Door” works as both a love song and a cautionary tale about rushing into a relationship. “In Summer” is surreally hilarious and even “Fixer Upper,” while not 100% necessary, possesses an infectiously catchy beat nonetheless.
“Frozen II” sees the return of song-writing team Robert Lopez and Kristen Anderson-Lopez and the score’s composer, Christophe Beck. Just as the story is more grown-up, their music sounds more sophisticated too. We still get a couple upbeat songs like “Some Things Never Change” and “When I Am Older,” as well as a retro 80s tune from Kristoff entitled “Lost in the Woods.” The best songs are the ones that bring out the inner demons and desires of our characters, such as “Into the Unknown,” “The Next Right Thing,” and “Show Yourself.” These songs take Elsa and Anna to bold new places, signifying their growth.
While we’ll be listening to both of these soundtracks until the end of time, let’s be honest. “Into the Unknown” is “Let It Go 2.0” and “Show Yourself” is “Let It Go 3.0.” “Frozen II” even begrudgingly acknowledges that the first film has a legacy in its music that’s hard to run from, making “Frozen” this round’s victory.
WINNER: Frozen 3 / Frozen II 1
Round 5: Messages & Themes
True love has always been a staple of Disney, but “Frozen” demonstrates how this doesn’t only apply to romance. Familial love can be just as meaningful, if not more so. Granted, “Frozen” wasn’t the first Disney movie to explore the bond of sisterhood, as “Lilo & Stitch” also had a touching relationship between Lilo and Nani. Where that was a subplot, though, Anna and Elsa’s connection is the focal point of “Frozen.” Learning that true love comes in many different forms, Anna becomes more careful with who she gives her heart to while Elsa finally starts opening up her heart to others.
Given its more adult tone, it makes sense that “Frozen II” would tackle themes of maturity and accepting change. At its core, however, this sequel is about learning to love oneself. As far as they’ve come from the first film, Anna remains codependent on others while Elsa is still coming to terms with the mysterious magic within herself. By the conclusion, Anna not only grows more independent, but also finds the strength and confidence to make difficult decisions on her own. Elsa walks away with a better understanding of who she is and where she belongs. Yet, neither loses sight of their loved ones.
These two films - just like the sisters - form a complete whole. Ideas that were introduced in the first film, like figuring out who you are and the different kinds of love, get elaborated upon with the importance of self-love in the sequel. “Frozen II” elevates “Frozen” in key ways, but you can't have one without the other. So, we’re calling this round a tie.
WINNER: Frozen 3 / Frozen II 2
They may finish each other’s sandwiches, but “Frozen” is ultimately the more well-thought out and rewatchable film, winning this versus with a final score of 3 to 2.
Sign in
to access this feature